Episode 25 - In which a ninja is caught, kinky sex turns deadly and if you don’t listen, Ewell be sorry!

August 28, 2017

Ninja Burglad sounds kind of badass, but this one deserves every second of the 22 years he ends up with! Also, two different killers murder their family members, but is it for money or something else?


Episode 24 - In which a girl’s life is forever changed, peanut butter is a weapon, and a fire takes over.

August 21, 2017

Sometimes people are evil. Sometimes they are careless. This episode has some of each. A young girl is snatched off the street on her way to school, and her life is never the same. A couple of men think they're above the law and value profit over life, and a handful of partiers learn a very, very hard lesson!


Episode 23 - In which we forget how to podcast, but still tell stories of accidental murder, celebrity arrests, and tunafish

August 15, 2017

Maybe so much coffee wasn't a great idea! Jordan and I are joined by our silent but handy sound guy as we answer Mike's Mike's challenge (no, that's not a typo), talk about the number 23, and try to figure out how someone could accidentally poison a crowd!


Episode 22 - In which two girls make a deadly, almost supernatural pact, a woman blames a murder on sex, and we learn that you’re not allowed to ride couches through drive-thrus!

August 7, 2017

If you've never heard of The Silent Twins, you have to listen to this episode! Yes, it's true crime, but something about it also seems... otherworldly! 

Then Jordan tells about a marriage that was doomed before it began. 

And Eryn finishes up with a hilarious tale of midnight munchies gone horribly awry!


(Sound effects courtesy of ZapSplat)


Episode 21 - In which it IS twins, is only one guy, and is also Five Guys

July 31, 2017

And if that's not enough to confuse you, listen on!

Jordan tells of a murderer who manages to avoid conviction by being someone else and a man who really just had the munchies. Eryn tells of a crime of potential mistaken identity. And both of us almost get eaten by a GIANT SPIDER!


Episode 20 - In which a tiger gets loose, the OG finally makes an appearance, and an itty bitty place hides a big murder!

July 24, 2017

It's our 20th episode! Jordan and I celebrate by traveling coast to coast. From Oregon to NY to Texas, and Cali, we chat about 1920s gangsters, loose felines, and a massive murder in the least-expected place!


Episode 19 - In which we head to the BB B&B, talk about a Crabby criminal, and hear about a loser with an unusual weapon!

July 17, 2017

This episode is full of puns (we are sorry), but also awesomeness. If you're a Harry Potter fan, a small-town Maine resident, or if you like (or don't like) "belly-legged" animals, give Episode 19 a listen!


Episode 18 - In which a fire starts, there’s mistaken identity, and a guy creates his own technicality

July 10, 2017

A fire results in 3 deaths, and someone has to take the blame. However, things aren’t always what they seem.

Speaking of which, a man is murdered and his ex is arrested. But, it’s her SISTER who flew into town.

Also, a small update on the murder near us!


Episode 17 - In which we take on a challenge and answer with awesomeness and LLAMAS!

July 4, 2017

Neville, we hear your challenge, we accept, and we think we did an awesome job!

From llamas in Peru to Fantastic Beasts travel plans to E-mbezzlement by J-ulia (and a healthy dose of us drooling over some adorable puppies!) - this episode is our favorite so far!


Episode 16 - In which we dive into the depths, get away with murder, and hide in an attic!

June 27, 2017

Special Guest and former student Faith joins this week's podcast, and she's brought an amazing story to share. Seriously. There may be ghosts!

Jordan and her angel of death make Eryn slightly furious, but she returns the favor with a mystery in a coral reef!